Showing posts with label Christian Sexuality. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Christian Sexuality. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 31, 2024

My Top Books of 2024

In the realm of reading, this last year was very much like previous years* for me.

It turns out that I even completed the exact same number of books (64) as I had in 2023. I continued to mine similar quarries and read in the same veins–authors, genres, subjects. I actually re-read about a dozen books from previous years, some for the fifth time!

All the same, I never felt like I was spinning my wheels in a rut. The “more of the same” is simply just more of the same blessing. It felt like forward progress. I’m still regaining some of the ground I had lost from more productive pre-pandemic years gone by and maintaining what I had attained through my restorative sabbatical. My reading goals have been more modest and right-sized so I feel good about what I’ve accomplished.

In 2024, I was exposed to some pretty terrific books!


This book was the happiest surprise of 2024. As I said in my incandescent review, “I have been searching for a book like More to the Story for a very long time. As a Christian pastor, I want the young people I care for to have really good answers to the difficult questions they are all asking about sexuality these days. And to be really good answers for today’s teens, they have to be realistic, biblical, confident, joyful, hopeful, comprehensive, concise, and readable. That’s a tall order!

How pleasant it was for me to discover that one of my EFCA friends had written such a book.”

Jennifer’s book is well-deserving of the various accolades it has received, including the award of merit from Christianity Today. It is simply excellent and just what the church needs in our day.


Fred Sanders’ latest book is the one I most needed in 2024. He introduced me to Someone I already know intimately but often don’t understand. It is chock-ful of “aha” paragraphs. As you might expect from his previous work, Fred hasn’t just written a book about One Person of the Trinity but the entire Trinity in relation to the Third Person of the Trinity. The appendix with “27 Rules for Thinking Well About the Holy Spirit” distills the whole book and is worth the proverbial price of it. 

Sanders’ writing is robust, rich, deep, and erudite and yet, at the same time, concise, clear, and even playful. It’s the not most hardest theological book I read in 2024, but the best. I will be re-reading The Holy Spirit: An Introduction again very soon.


Most people (not just Christians) have heard of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien because of the tremendous reach of The Chronicles of Narnia and The Lord of the Rings. But many people do not know that these two Oxford-scholars-turned-popular-authors were close friends or how their fellowship spurred on the creation and publication of their fantastical stories.

In The Mythmakers, New York Times bestselling, award-winning creator John Hendrix has beautifully crafted a unique way of spreading the story of their collaborative friendship. I knew the outline of the story and had even gotten to visit some of the key locations where it all happened during our sabbatical in 2023 (The Kilns, Addison’s Walk, The Eagle and Child), but I still learned a lot, especially how all of the different parts were connected, and I thoroughly enjoyed how Hendrix wove his tale with both words and images. There is nothing quite like it.

I really enjoyed listening to Hendrix talk about the book at The Habit Podcast and The Wade Center Podcast.


Ed Welch has the gift of saying just the thing (and everything!) you need to hear in just a few well-chosen words. 

Ed’s book speaks light in a way that someone experiencing the stubborn darkness can actually hear. Depressed people often can’t read more than a few words at a time. These thirty-one short readings are apples of gold in settings of silver for those who are under the heavy weight of depression (Proverbs 25:11).

Depression: Finding Christ in the Darkness is a good book to read if you love people who live with depression, even if you don’t experience it yourself. Ed knows how to talk about it without mixing in shame while at the same time illuminating a new path that sinner/sufferer/saints are called to walk.


Here is another extremely timely book. When I recommended it in The Family Table, our weekly newsletter for parents at Lanse Free Church, I said, “Every Christian parent with young children should read this book right away. Parenting Without Panic in an LGBT-Affirming World should be required reading for raising a little kid in today’s culture. Given her own story, Rachel Gilson is a perfect person to write it. Her earlier memoir Born Again This Way was one of my top books of 2020, and I’m very glad that she’s now giving out this practical, well-written, insightful, realistic, and biblically balanced advice. I wish it was written earlier! I especially appreciate how Gilson counters all the big fears we all feel. These fears are not baseless, but they should not define or drive us. Read this, soak in the principles, prepare your kids, and fear not!”

It turns out that I read several books on this and related subjects this year in addition to Kvamme and Gilson which were really good. Purposeful Sexuality by Ed Shaw explains what sex is actually for in a few concise and pages. In the same series, Andrew Bunt’s Finding Your Best Identity, helpfully explores the question of who or what gets to define who you are. In Does the Bible Affirm Same-Sex Relationships?, Rebecca McLaughlin responds to the ten strongest arguments from those who claim the Bible affirms (or doesn't teach about) same-sex romantic/sexual relationships. Written by a woman herself who experiences persistent same-sex attraction. McLaughlin is a treasure, well-read, and an excellent communicator. In 2024, I also read her No Greater Love which covers the concept of biblical friendship.

I am very grateful for the blessing of having so many great books in my life. 


***

* This is my eleventh time sharing a list like this! (I didn't get one out in 2019.)

As I’ve said for over a decade [2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2023], this list is not necessarily the best books that were published that particular year or the most enjoyable either. I intend it to be a list of the fairly new Christian nonfiction books I read:

- that had the most personal impact on me, my thinking, my heart.
- that I was the most consistently enthusiastic about.
- that I kept coming back to again and again.
- that I couldn't help recommending to others (and recommend without reservations and significant caveats).

Friday, May 03, 2024

“More to the Story” by Jennifer Kvamme

I have been searching for a book like this for a very long time.

As a Christian pastor, I want the young people I care for to have really good answers to the difficult questions they are all asking about sexuality these days. And to be really good answers for today’s teens, they have to be realistic, biblical, confident, joyful, hopeful, comprehensive, concise, and readable. That’s a tall order!

How pleasant it was for me to discover that one of my EFCA friends had written such a book.

Jennifer Kvamme is Student Ministries Catalyst at Centennial Church in Forest Lake, Minnesota. She and I have collaborated on EFCA publications in the past, and when I heard about More to the Story: Deep Answers to Real Questions on Attraction, Identity, and Relationships, I was eager to hear what she had to say.

Jennifer writes as a true friend and wise mentor. She is sensitive to her young readers’ feelings and gentle with past hurts and poor decisions. Life is gritty, confusing, and painful. At the same time, Jennifer is joyful, confident, and unwavering in holding out God’s good design for sexuality. In three opening chapters and then at every turning point across the rest of the book, Jennifer embeds all the biblical teaching on sexuality in the grand storyline of the Scriptures. Sexuality is a grand glimpse of something deeper. There is more to the story. And the ultimate hero of the story gets the credit He deserves for His compassion and redemption. Jesus is fixing what has been broken so that following Him will be worth it all.

More to the Story does it all. I no longer have to point teens to a little library of resources I have assembled to address the long list of questions they have. Jennifer covers the waterfront in concise chapters that each end with meaningful questions for personal reflection. Students that need or want to go deeper can follow the endnotes or read her annotated recommendations for further reading. Youth groups can utilize the well-written discussion guide to jumpstart great conversations. The folks at The Good Book Company have done a beautiful job of laying out the book’s design to undergird its message.

While I’m sure it’s not perfect, I don’t have any real critique to offer. Unlike most books on this topic, I never had to wince as I read it. I never wished that Jennifer had said something differently or “not gone there.” Her counsel is sound, balanced, robust, and hope-giving. It’s even humorous at appropriate times! As all other books on this topic, More to the Story will feel dated at some point, probably frustratingly soon. Life is just getting more complicated. But this book is simply excellent and just what the church needs in our day.

I wish we had this book when our own kids were teens, but I’m glad we have it now. Highly recommended.

Give a copy of More to the Story to every sixteen-year-old you know.

Sunday, June 09, 2019

"The Lord of Marriage" [Matt's Messages]

“The Lord of Marriage”
Following Jesus - The Gospel of Matthew
June 9, 2019 :: Matthew 19:1-12

Matthew 19 marks the beginning of a new section in the Gospel of Matthew. Jesus has finished his 4th major block of teaching and is now headed towards Jerusalem.

And on His way, He runs into several different people and has some significant interactions with them, which we might call “teachable moments.”

Today, it’s some Pharisees, and they have a test for Him on His theology of marriage.

How do you think that’s going to go?

Here’s a life-hack for you. A pro-tip for living:

Never try to lay a trap for Jesus.

Unless you like falling into your own traps!

“When Jesus had finished saying these things, he left Galilee and went into the region of Judea to the other side of the Jordan. Large crowds followed him, and he healed them there.”

Here is Jesus marching towards Jerusalem.

You and I know what is going to happen there.

And Jesus knows what’s going to happen there.

But everybody else is still kind of in the dark.

In verse 1, Jesus finishes His teaching on humility and being great in the kingdom and God’s love for the little ones and the importance of resolving our conflicts and forgiving one another. And then He leaves the North and heads South towards Jerusalem.

And the crowds begin to form.

And, as He has done throughout this book, Jesus heals the sick in those crowds.

And then in verse 3, some Pharisees come, and they see the good work that Jesus is doing, and they see how the crowds are following Him, and they are convinced by His words that He is the Messiah, and they bow before Him and lead the nation to follow Him themselves.

Just kidding. LOL. That’s not at all what they do!

That’s what they should do, but it’s not what they do.

No, they come to Jesus and try to trap Him. V.3

“Some Pharisees came to him to test him. They asked, ‘Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife for any and every reason?’”

“Let’s give Jesus a test and see if He passes.”

They are not sincere.

They are not asking this question to find out the truth.

They have an agenda with this question.

They want to trap Jesus.

How does that work?

Well, there was a big debate during this time about the theology of divorce.

There were two major schools of thought. The school of Rabbi Shammai and the school of Rabbi Hillel.

Rabbi Shammai said that God requires divorce only in the case of adultery. But Rabbi Hillel said that God allows divorce any time a man is unhappy with his wife. Even if she burns dinner or her eyebrows get too bushy.

And the Pharisees think that they can trap Jesus with this question.

“Which side are you on?”

“If you side with Rabbi Hillel, and anything goes, doesn’t that contradict what you said at the Sermon on the Mount? And where does it all end?

But if you side with Rabbi Shammai (and I think that’s what they hope He will do), then you might get into trouble with Herod Antipas.”

Remember Him? Remember what happened to John the Baptist when He made a pronouncement about some divorce being against God’s law?

Prison first. And then off with his head.

They think they’ve got Him.

Maybe they’ve even stumped Him.

Can Jesus answer this stumper of a question?

What do you think?

I entitled this message, “The Lord of Marriage.”

Because Jesus is not just the Lord of the Sabbath or the Lord of all of the other things we’ve seen Him master in this book.

He is also the Lord over marriage.

Not only does Jesus have a theology of marriage, His theology flows from His own authority.

The Pharisees obviously don’t recognize this or they wouldn’t be asking the question this way, but that’s their mistake.

Jesus pushes back. V.4

“‘Haven't you read,’ he replied, ‘that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'? So they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate.’”

It’s always a sick burn when Jesus says, “Haven’t you read your Bibles?”

They think they have Him stumped, and He says, “I think the answer to that one is on the first page of your Bible. Haven’t you read it?”

“I think you’re missing the point. Let’s go back and look.”

And Jesus leads them on a Bible study of Genesis 1 and 2.

Jesus is saying that they are starting in the wrong place with their questions.

We’ll see that they are starting with Deuteronomy 24, but the Jesus says, “You’ve got to go back further than that or you’ll be missing the point.”

And speaking of points, I have three points of application for today’s message.

Here’s the first:

#1. TRUST THE DESIGNER TO DEFINE MARRIAGE.

V.4 again.

“‘Haven't you read,’ he replied, ‘that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'? So they are no longer two, but one.

Marriage is God’s idea.

He designed it.

It’s not something that we came up with.

It came from (v.4), “the Creator.”

The Designer.

The Original Lord of Marriage.

Marriage is God’s idea, and so we should get our ideas of what marriage should be from Him.  Make sense?

Obviously, this flies in the face of so much of our modern culture, including among Christians.

We want to define marriage our own way.

We want to do what we want to do with it.

And we figure that God (if He exists) just has to be okay with that.

But that’s exactly wrong.

He is the Lord of Marriage. We need to listen to Him.

This passage (vv.4-6) is very relevant to a whole host of contemporary issues and questions.

It addresses marriage and also divorce.

It also addresses same-sex marriage and transgenderism, doesn’t it?

It has implications for those.

Because Jesus says Genesis 1 says that humans are made male and female. Remember when we talked about that back in February? 

Two biological sexes. Different and complementary. Male and female, not interchangeable. Not changeable. And it was “tov” It was good.

And here’s what marriage is:

Jesus says that Genesis 2 says that a man (1 man, this passage addresses bigamy and polygamy, too, a man) will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife (1 biological woman), and the two will become one flesh. So they are no longer two, but one.

So here’s God’s math:

One plus one equals one.

One man and one woman come together to be one flesh.

That’s the design.

Don’t believe it if people tell you that Jesus never said anything about same-sex marriage.

Jesus said, “I agree with Genesis.”

The Creator has designed marriage, and it is good.

By the way, this passage also addresses co-habitation, doesn’t it?

Living together as if you are married when you aren’t.

That is not how God designed the one flesh relationship.

The one flesh relationship is for a husband and a wife.

Two people who have de-prioritized all other loyalties and then re-prioritized each other as their number one loyalty on earth so that they have actually formed a new entity, a new family, a new unity.

“So they are no longer two, but one.”

That’s what marriage, and it’s where sex belongs.

“One flesh” means more than just sex, but it doesn’t mean less.

Two bodies coming together in sexual intimacy is for marriage, by God’s design.

I say, “Trust the Designer” because I want to emphasize that when we obey the Lord of Marriage, we are trusting that He knows best.

Because it doesn’t always seem that way.

I know that some people have same-sex attraction, persistent same-sex attraction. And they want to marry somebody of the same sex, and it seems like that would be really good to them.

But that’s not how the Creator designed marriage. That’s not what marriage is.

And the Lord of Marriage is calling us to trust Him to do things His way and be blessed.

I know that some people suffer from gender dysphoria. They feel great unease about their own bodies. They would rather be the other sex than they were born.

I empathize with that pain. It must be very great, and I don’t pretend to know the half of it.

But I do know that my Creator is good and His design for creation is good.

And I know that I can trust Him.

And I know that some people are wary of marriage. They think it’s just a piece of paper. They have seen the ravages of divorce. They want to make sure that this person they want to be with is the right person, and so they want to test drive the relationship and live like they’re married before they are married just to make sure. And there are, unfortunately in some cases, financial benefits to living together instead of getting married.

But that’s not how God designed it.

That’s going against the grain of the universe.

As is polygamy. And, as we’ll see, as is divorce.

Jesus is asking us to trust the Lord of Marriage and do it His way.

You see his application? V.6

“Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate.”

Application point number two:

#2. DON’T RUSH TO AMPUTATE WHAT THE LORD HAS STITCHED.

“[W]hat God has joined together, let man not separate.’”

What has God joined together?

He calls it “one flesh.”

Now, it’s just a metaphor, but what a picture that is!

It’s like one man surgically sewn together with one woman to form a new unity.

And after the surgery heals, there’s just one entity there.

And Who is the surgeon?

“What GOD has joined together.”

Marriage is not just something that two people do to themselves.

It’s not even just something that the state does to two people.

Jesus says that God puts people together into marriages.

So we should be very careful about pulling them apart!

Do you see how this answers the Pharisees’ question?

They wanted to know when it was okay to divorce.

Jesus says, “Divorce?! Uh. That’s never ‘okay.’ That’s never best. That’s never good, never ‘tov.’ Divorce wasn’t the idea. Divorce wasn’t the design, the intention.”

Don’t do that if you can at all help it.

Don’t just amputate what the Lord has stitched together.

Now, I know that this is a painful subject for many us here.

We have all been touched by divorce in our families, and many of you have experienced divorces personally.

I know this painful.

For some of you, it’s painful because you didn’t want it, but it happened to you anyway.

For some of you, it’s painful because you know you did it wrong, and you feel the weight of that.

For some of you, it's painful because you're going through it right now.

For some of you, most of you, you feel some degree of shame. Even if you didn’t do anything shameful in the whole process, you still feel shame put on you by others. Even what I’ve said so far this morning might seem to pile it on further.

There is confusion and hurt. When you let someone into your life so that they get all the way to one-flesh, and then that relationship breaks and becomes jagged, it’s got to hurt. Being in conflict and estranged and eventually divided from the person who was the closest person to you has got to hurt and have lingering effects.

I know that divorces are painful.

And so does the Lord.

And divorce, even sinful divorce, is not the unforgivable sin.

And not all divorces are sinful (at least on one side) as we’ll see in verse 9.

But Jesus is saying that divorce should be avoided if at all possible.

We should be extremely reluctant to divorce.

Because what God has joined together is something we should not separate.

That’s not how it was designed.

Marriage wasn’t designed to be temporary.

It was to be dissolved only by death.

So the Pharisees have a comeback.

They don’t realize that they have already lost.

They whip out Deuteronomy 24:1, and think they have answered Him. V.7

“‘Why then,’ they asked, ‘did Moses command that a man give his wife a certificate of divorce and send her away?’ [Huh, Jesus? Riddle me that! Answer that one!]

Jesus replied, [You numbskulls] ‘Moses permitted you to divorce your wives because your hearts were hard. But it was not this way from the beginning.”

Notice that word “permitted.”

Here’s where Jesus differs from Rabbi Shammai.

He thought that if there was adultery, then God required a divorce.

“No,” Jesus says, “God through Moses permitted a divorce in those cases because of hard hearts, but He didn’t command them.”

You don’t have to divorce even when there has been sexual immorality.

That’s not the way it was is in the beginning.

The design was for permanence.

Marriage was built to last.

Yes, we messed it all up. Hard hearts. Lots of sin. Lots of covenant breaking.

Yes, divorce got allowed. (Even polygamy gets allowed for a time.)

But that wasn’t the design.

Don’t rush out and get a divorce!

Make every effort.
Make every effort.
Make every effort you can to salvage that thing.

I know that’s not what the world says.

The world rushes to divorce.

And so do many professing Christians.

And again, there are solid reasons to divorce, as we’ll see in verse 9.

And if you have divorced for the wrong reasons, there is plenty grace at the Cross for all repentant sinners.

But the Lord of Marriage says, “Don’t rush to amputate what I have sewn together.”

Make every effort.

Divorce should be a last resort.

Remember the last chapter.

Remember the amazing grace of forgiveness.

How much we have been forgiven, which gives us the power to unleash much forgiveness into our relationships.

Make every effort.

Because, verse 9:

“I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife, except for marital unfaithfulness, and marries another woman commits adultery.”

Now, you hear the exception there. And there is at least one other exception that Paul lays out in 1 Corinthians 7, abandonment by an unbelieving spouse.

But the emphasis here isn’t on the exception of sexual immorality, the Greek is “porneia” from which we get our word “porn” and it means various kinds of covenant breaking marital sexual unfaithfulness.

The emphasis isn’t on the exception.

It’s on the fact that if you divorce and remarry for the wrong reasons, you are committing adultery, breaking the 7th commandment.

You’re badly amputating what the Lord has sewn together.

And notice by Whose word this is. V.9

“I tell you...”

Don’t miss that! That’s super important.

Remember, this is the Gospel of Matthew. Keep your eye on the ball!

Who does this guy think He is?

He thinks He’s the Lord of Marriage!

It’s like the Sermon on the Mount.

“Moses said this, but I tell you...”

Don’t do it.

Don’t divorce for the wrong reasons.

“What God has joined together, let man not separate.”

Now, there is an exception here.

And it’s a true one. If one spouse falls into marital unfaithfulness (porneia), they are in that moment ripping up the surgery themselves and defacing the one-flesh relationship.

If your spouse has done that to you, you are permitted by the Lord of Marriage to divorce them.

Permitted, not commanded!

I’d still say, “Make every effort.”

“Make every effort.”

Even when it doesn’t feel like it.

Because we know that our marriages are pictures of Christ and the Church.

And if we can salvage them, they can still be wonderfully beautiful pictures of Christ and the Church.

We should be extremely reluctant to throw away any pictures of Christ and the Church.

But it is permitted, especially if they are unrepentant.

If they are amputating what the Lord has stitched together, you certainly don’t have to pretend that all is well.

But the Lord of Marriage wants us to do everything we can to uphold it.

Now, the disciples overreact to what Jesus has just taught. V.10

“The disciples said to him, ‘If this is the situation between a husband and wife, it is better not to marry.’”

I’m pretty sure that was Peter!

Sounds like him, doesn’t it?

He was married already. He knew that marriage was a lot of work.

And now Jesus says that it’s for better, for worse, and for keeps.

You might feel trapped in a marriage if it’s for life. A life sentence.

What’s fascinating is that even though that’s a rash overreaction, Jesus basically says, “Yeah, that’s right for some people.”

For some people it is better to not marry. V.11

“Jesus replied, ‘Not everyone can accept this word, but only those to whom it has been given. [There’s three kinds.] For some are eunuchs because they were born that way; others were made that way by men; and others have renounced marriage [or became eunuchs] because of the kingdom of heaven. The one who can accept this should accept it.’”

So, surprisingly, our last application point is:

#3. SERIOUSLY CONSIDER CELIBACY FOR THE KINGDOM.

Ironically, the Lord of Marriage says that marriage is not for everyone.

Some people are (at least for a time and some for a lifetime) called to celibate singleness.

And that’s not strange.

We think that’s so strange.

We think that’s so hard.

“Celibacy is so hard!”

But Jesus says, “Marriage is hard. Celibacy is just a different kind of hard.”

You know what’s hard?

Being born a eunuch. Being celibate because your body came out that way.

Being celibate because somebody did that to you.

It’s actually much easier to choose to live the celibate lifestyle than to have forced on you.

And what if you choose it for the kingdom?

Isn’t that quite a phrase in verse 12, “because of the kingdom of heaven.”

I read a quote yesterday from Douglas O’Donnell that really struck me.

He said, “The kingdom of heaven is so important that it should seem perfectly normal if someone would want to give up marriage for it.”

There are a bunch of reasons why it can be advantageous for the kingdom for you to stay single, at least for a time, and for some a life-time.

And if you are called to that, embrace it. “The one who can accept this should accept this.”

And those of us who are married should celebrate those who are single right now for the kingdom.

I think, all too often, we’ve treated singles as second-class kingdom citizens.

But that’s totally wrong. The Apostle Paul talks about this in 1 Corinthians 7, as well.

Single Christians are first-class kingdom citizens if they are living for the Lord.

And this church has an awesome history of having wonderful single people in it serving the Lord.

And there are many right here in this room today.

If you are single right now and serving the Lord, thank you.

Thank you for being celibate.

Thank you for being devoted.

Thank you for using your singleness for the Kingdom.

You know who you are like?

You’re like the Apostle Paul.

And you’re like the Lord Jesus Christ.

Because ironically, the Lord of Marriage never got married Himself.

Or perhaps better to say, He’s still engaged to be married to the Church His Bride, and we await the Wedding Supper of the Lamb when all earthly marriages will be o over and we all will have in full what they all pointed to in part, the relationship between the Lord of Marriage and His Church.

What a glorious day that will be!


***

Previous Messages in This Series:
01. The Genealogy of Jesus
02. The Birth of Jesus Christ
03. The Search for Jesus Christ
04. The Baptism of Jesus
05. The Temptation of Jesus
06. Following Jesus
07. Jesus' Sermon on the Mount
08. The Good Life (Part One)
09. The Good Life (Part Two)
10. You Are The...
11. Jesus and the First 2/3 of the Bible
12. But I Tell You
13. But I Tell You (2)
14. But I Tell You (3)
15. In Secret
16. Choose Wisely
17. Seek First His Kingdom
18. Generous
19. These Words of Mine
20. When He Saw the Crowds
21. When He Came Down from the Mountainside
22. Follow Me
23. Our Greatest Problem
24. Who Does He Think He Is?
25. Special Agents
26. Sheep Among Wolves
27. What To Expect On Your Mission
28. Are You the One?
29. Come to Me
30. The King of Rest
31. So Thankful!
32. Overflow
33. This Wicked Generation
34. Get It?
35. What Is Really Going On Here?
36. Baptizing the Disciples
37. The Treasure of the Kingdom
38. Living the Last Beatitude
39. Five Loaves, Two Fish, and Jesus
40. It Is I.
41. Worthless Worship
42. Great Faith in a Great God
43. The Pharisees and Sadducees
44. The Question and the Promise
45. Take Up His Cross
46. Like the Sun
47. Seed-Sized Faith
48. These Little Ones

Monday, December 29, 2014

Virginity, Chastity, and Christianity

Recently, a good friend sent a link an article at thoughtcatalog called, "I Waited Until My Wedding Night to Lose My Virginity, and I Wish I Hadn't."  [My Covenant Eyes filter won't allow me to view this link, so there may be other material on the site that is suggestive, objectionable, and/or problematic. Use discretion.]

This autobiographical article is about a young woman who had fully embraced her church's strong emphasis on the importance of virginity before marriage and then was woefully unprepared for the painful realities of sex within marriage. She tells her story which is fairly raw and angry and then concludes:
I'm now thoroughly convinced that the entire concept of virginity is used to control female sexuality. If I could go back, I would not wait. I would have sex with my then-boyfriend-now-husband and I wouldn't go to hell for it. We would have gotten married at a more appropriate age and I would have kept my sexuality to myself. Unfortunately, I can't go back but I can give you this message as a culmination of my experiences: If you want to wait to have sex until marriage make sure it's because you want to. It's your body; it belongs to you, not your church. Your sexuality is nobody's business but yours.
My friend, who is not convinced of biblical Christianity right now, wanted my take on it because he hadn't heard this perspective shared before and wanted to know what a pastor would make of it.

When I shared the contents of my response letter to my friend with my wife, she suggested that it was worth posting for others to read.

***

Dear [X],

Sorry it took so long to get back to you. Life has been very full recently.

Thanks for sending me this link and asking my opinion. It sparked a lot of thoughts for me and it took me a while to put them into a coherent form. Hope this is helpful to you.

My main feeling after reading “I Waited Until My Wedding...” was sadness.

First, I was sad because the author had such a painful experience. I feel bad for her that she experienced shame, pain, and confusion. I’m sorry to hear how difficult her first few years of marriage were.

Second, I was sad because her church had done such a poor job of teaching her the biblical truth about sexuality. Either she wasn’t listening very well or they had sold her a different story than the Bible tells. For example:

- She talks about a double standard for men than women. She got the idea that chastity was only for women and not men. Apparently, her church taught her this.

- She indicates that her church taught her that God was obligating Himself to give her a perfect life if she remained a virgin until marriage. Like it’s a contract that God signed and something is owed to her. That’s a very unbiblical notion of how God operates. Though she could expect blessing to come from her obedience, there is no promise in the Bible that it would take the “fairy tale” forms that she thought she had been promised. The Bible is messier, grittier, and truer than that.

- She seems to have been taught that sexual sin would have sent her to Hell in a way that other sins wouldn’t. Perhaps her church didn’t teach the wickedness of other sins. It also seems like they didn’t emphasize the gospel of grace which both forgives believers of sins and empowers them to say “No” to temptation.

- Nobody seems to have prepared her for how sex within marriage will actually be. It’s important to do that, but difficult, too. I try to do this to some degree in pre-marital counseling, but it’s hard to find good places to do it. I’m not going to teach on it very often with a mixed generation and mixed gender audience. But, at least her Mom should have been preparing her for that. [I have no idea why she waited so long for marriage, either. She doesn’t say how what she was taught plays into that decision.]

- The focus seems to have been on virginity not chastity. That’s a big mistake that her church apparently made. She should not have felt dirty when she got home because her virginity was gone. She should have felt some joy that her sexuality was being fulfilled in a God-honoring way. Our sexuality is a wonderful, God-designed reality embedded in a broken world. It seems like her teachers missed that balance almost completely.

Third, I was sad that the author had exchanged one set of lies for another. Instead of going to her Bible to see what God really says about sex, she has left God behind and embraced the religion of self. Having sex before marriage wouldn’t have solved her problems but would have created other ones including alienation from God, probable promiscuity, loss of specialness of their marriage bond, and selfishness in sex. For every one story like hers, I believe that there are thousands of testimonies of shame and regret for having forsaken biblical chastity and given up too much too soon.

It’s really sad to hear her say that her body belongs to herself. No, it doesn’t belong to the church of her youth. But her body is a stewardship from God for which she is accountable to Him some day. I’m happy that she’s currently happy in her relationship with her husband, but I have very little hope for it to remain that way if her focus is completely upon herself and her “needs.” And I’m very concerned with what she is teaching others now. I’m sad that she both doesn’t properly see what happened to her and that she has swung so far away from the truth.

That’s my two cents. Thanks for honoring me by asking.

-Matt

Wednesday, July 30, 2014

17 Recommended Resources on Same-Sex Attraction


The Biblical Counseling Coalition has just published my list of the resources that were the most helpful to me as I prepared to talk about homosexuality at the Challenge Conference earlier this month.

Previous posts about the conference and holy sexuality:

Help! How Do I Think About Homosexuality?
Restored: Challenge Report to Lanse Free Church
Help! How Do I Think About Homosexuality? Teaching Notes
Hope for Holy Sexuality

Wednesday, June 19, 2013

Torn About “Torn” 2 - Three Things that Disturbed Me Most

It’s been over a month since my last post on Torn by Justin Lee. Life seems to keep interfering with my ability to interact publicly with this important book.

But now that the official editing phase for Resisting Gossip has been completed, I want to try to turn my attention back to Torn and share some of my concerns about its message. Originally, I had envisioned a multi-week series laying out my disagreements one at a time. But now I think it would best to simply share the thoughts I consider the most important all at once.  (Who knows when I would get back to finish a longer series?)

As I’ve said before, I really wanted to like Torn because it came highly recommended to me and because its subtitle promised to rescue the gospel–some had said that it was the “game changer” that we all need. There were things that I appreciated about the book.

But in the end, I was disappointed with Torn and, more than that, disturbed by it. I wrote a note to myself inside the front cover to remind me of my final evaluation of the book. It said, “Dangerous and destructive. A Trojan horse. I think I heard Satan’s voice.”

I know those are strong words, but they are what I thought and felt after I’d read Torn.

Let me share with you the three major areas that disturbed me most:

#1. Torn Offers No Hope for Change.

The most disheartening word in the book is not “gay” but “orientation.”

Justin Lee has come to the conclusion that “gay” is the way someone simply is, they are “oriented that way” and there is almost no chance of someone who is gay becoming “straight” (see pgs. 234-237). This conclusion comes from Justin’s own story. It resonates with his experience of repeatedly trying to change and failing. And it fits with the stories many other people have told him.

Justin is agnostic about the origin of this orientation though he guesses that biology plays a significant role (pgs. 68-69). But the fact of orientation is something of which he is certain and the whole book rests upon it.  A key chapter is titled “Why are people gay?”  And while wrestling with that question, the question itself assumes that “gay” is something you ARE.

The word “orientation” tells a powerful, controlling story. A story of identity. A story that is fixed.  This story of orientation has captured the minds and hearts of this generation, but I’m not at all sure that it’s a true story.

What is sexual attraction, exactly?  Is sexual attraction something that is fixed and permanent? Or is it fluid and changeable?  I don’t believe that this question has yet been definitively answered.

Even if homosexuality has, as some evidence begins to point towards, a strong biological component, that still doesn’t mean that “gay is something you just are.”  Perhaps it would be better to say, “Same sex attraction is something you have” as in “I have attractions to people of my own gender” or “I have homosexual desires.”

And maybe that’s all that Justin means by his words “gay orientation,” but that’s not the story that I hear when I read his book. When I read Torn, I hear that there is no hope for someone in this situation to change.

But the whole point of this series of blog posts was to offer hope to Christians who have felt trapped in homosexuality and to share some stories of people who have experienced personal transformation. [People like Jackie, Christopher, Allan, Sam, Vaughn, Tim, Christy, and Rosaria.]

I am still convinced that 1 Corinthians 6 teaches that Christ-followers can overcome the sin of homosexuality (1 Cor 6:9-11).  That may not mean that they now have consistent opposite-sex attraction or even that they no longer have any same-sex attraction, but it would mean that they could escape from homosexual lust and actions.

I understand that not everyone wants hope for change in this way. Many will resonate with Justin’s word “orientation” and his conclusion that change is not possible. They believe that they are or can be happy in their present condition. But I find it fatalistic and depressing.

#2. Torn Tells Only Half of the Biblical Story.

The most disturbing chapter in Torn was called “Back to the Bible.”

In this chapter, Lee tells the story of re-reading with new eyes what he considered to be the most important passages in the Bible on homosexuality.

He retells the stories: of Sodom in Genesis 19 and Ezekiel 16, of the prohibition of a man lying with a man in Leviticus, of exchanging the natural for the unnatural in Romans 1, and of the identity of the arsenokoitai in 1 Corinthians 6. In each case, he offers an alternative interpretation that cast doubts on the traditional interpretation. In at least some of those cases, his alternatives might be reasonable.

Justin’s conclusion is that nothing is conclusive.

Here’s the problem: Lee seems even-handed. I believe that he’s trying to be even-handed!  But he’s left out some of the most important biblical data in understanding God’s design for human sexuality.

He’s left out what Jesus said.

When asked a tricky question about divorce, Jesus answered by referencing Genesis 1 & 2:

“‘Haven't you read,’ he replied, ‘that at the beginning the Creator 'made them male and female,' and said, 'For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh'? So they are no longer two, but one. Therefore what God has joined together, let man not separate’” (Matthew 19:4-6).

That is our Lord Jesus’ sexual ethic, and it’s not up for debate.

Sexual expression is made for marriage, and marriage is made for a man and woman (complementary sexual partners created by God as male and female) to leave their parents and then be united into one flesh.

Jesus’ sexual ethic is more than just heterosexuality (or “straightness”) but holy matrimony between a man and a woman.

Jesus wasn't silent on homosexuality [contra funny-man Stephen Colbert]. Jesus was clear on holy sexuality.

The Apostle Paul takes this even further in Ephesians 5 where he also quotes Genesis and connects the ultimate purpose of marriage to pointing towards Christ and the Church.

“‘For this reason a man will leave his father and mother and be united to his wife, and the two will become one flesh. This is a profound mystery–but I am talking about Christ and the church’” (Ephesians 5:30-31).

Where does complementarity between the created sexes go if we allow for same-sex sexual relationships? [See this excellent article in the Journal of Biblical Manhood and Womanhood on this very question.]

Justin Lee has a chapter alluding to Genesis 2, “That the Man Should Be Alone” where he does say that God gave Eve to Adam, but he apparently sees nothing programatic about this pattern for the rest of humanity throughout the ages (as I believe both Jesus and Paul do).

So, Lee only tells half of the biblical story, and therefore, doesn’t tell the true story.

Even if Lee’s alternative interpretations of Genesis 19, Leviticus 19, Romans 1, and 1 Corinthians 6 held a lot of water, they would only prove that certain kinds of homosexuality were proscribed, not that homosexuality was holy. I don’t think you can.

And I don’t think most of his exegetical points on those texts are valid, either. See Christopher Yuan’s gracious but truth-telling review of Torn, my old friend Dan Sullivan’s interactions, and Robert Gagnon’s magnum opus The Bible and Homosexual Practice: Texts and Hermeneutics for the other, more compelling side of those stories, too.

Lee ends his chapter on the Bible feeling like he can’t choose between the cup in front of him and the cup in front of his opponent, but I’m not even tempted by one of those cups.

Instead, all of his attempts to make a new interpretation seem tempting felt to me like the serpent in Genesis 3 asking Eve “Did God really say” that?

Now, hear me clearly, I’m not saying that Justin Lee is the devil’s advocate. But I do feel like he’s been listening to him without realizing it.

#3. Torn Suggests the Wrong Way Forward.

The best thing about Torn is that it teaches that Christians need to love others.

Justin Lee has seen the church repeatedly fail to love people with same-sex attraction. In fact, he’s seen that professing Christians have hated people with same-sex attraction, vilified them and demonized them. And in the name of hating-the-sin-yet-loving-the-sinner, Christians have also said a lot of goofy things that are misinformed (for example, that all homosexuals simply choose their desires, not just their behaviors).

And Lee is right to sound a clarion call for loving others. As I said before, I appreciate his emphasis on respect. I applaud Lee's call to listen to people with whom we disagree.

However, love does more than just respect and listen. Love also warns and challenges. Love calls people who are running in the wrong direction to turn around (repent) and change.  It is not love to affirm someone’s sin.

Love wants what is best for someone, and God has revealed what is best for us in His design for sexuality. Love will always want God’s best for someone and will not be content stand idly by while they hurt themselves.

In my estimation, Justin Lee does not call for enough love.  The kind of love that he is calling for does not go far enough.

I say that Torn is like a Trojan Horse because it sounds good, like an acceptable compromise, but in my opinion that compromise goes too far and lets enemy troops inside our walls.

It seems to me that Lee is too worried about Christianity’s P.R. problem. He is concerned that the rest of the world will tune out Christianity because of its rigid stance on sexuality.

And I agree that we have too often fallen into the ditch of hate and distancing ourselves from people with same-sex attraction–often because of sinful fear or unloving disgust. And when we have done that–we have marred the name of Christ and hampered our witness.

But the answer is not to career over the road into the ditch of compromise. The answer is to receive the rebuke we deserve, to correct our course, and to stick to the middle of the road–not to capitulate.

I can’t be responsible for what the world thinks of me or of Christianity. The world will often hate Christianity just for being Christianity.  I need to simply be true to Christ, and let the world form its own conclusions.

I think that Lee is wrong about what the way forward should be.

The way forward is to continue to truly love the sinner while hating the sin. Many of us haven’t really tried that yet.  As G.K. Chesterton said, “The Christian ideal has not been tried and found wanting. It has been found difficult; and left untried.”

While I learned a lot from listening to Justin Lee, and I think I could learn more, I don’t plan to follow him. I think he’s headed in the wrong direction.



***

I think I have one more post in this series on Torn (and probably the last major post in this ongoing series). While laying out my major concerns above, I haven't really interacted with Justin Lee's notions of using the rubric of self-giving love to break through the impasse between those who condemn homosexual relationships and those who affirm them. This is very important to Lee's argument, so I hope to write something about it in the weeks to come.

Wednesday, March 06, 2013

False Hope for Homosexuals


In our ongoing series on Hope for Holy Sexuality, I’ve been trying to highlight testimonies and resources that give hope for change to those who struggle with same-sex attraction.

One danger in doing that is to make it seem like there is a simple 3 (or even 12) step plan for attaining complete victory over homosexuality, easily changing all of your sexual desires to heterosexual, and one day being happily married to a opposite-sex spouse.  (Many of the “ex-gay” ministries have made claims like these that they can’t back up.)

The truth is that it is seldom simple or easy, and not everyone gets there (or they don't stay there consistently).


Over at Harvest USA, John Freeman wrote a multi-part series on why men fall back into homosexuality. That's part of the reality we live with in this battle.

But shouldn't that be obvious for Christians who have been saved, are still being saved, and look forward to the day when we are finally saved?


It’s important that at the same time as we promise Christians that they can have victory over sin (whatever that sin might be)--and they can!, that we remember that our battle with sin is ongoing and life-long. The battle is worth it and winable, but the victory may not always come when or look like we expected.

Let us offer hope, but not false hope for holy sexuality.

Wednesday, February 27, 2013

Pastor Vaughn Roberts on Same-Sex Attraction

One thing I've said that has been helpful to those who come to me with questions about Christianity and homosexuality is that we are all sexually broken, but we aren't all celebrating it.

In this interview Pastor Vaughn Roberts talks about his battle with same sex attraction and how he doesn't let that define him:

Does the disclosure that same sex attraction is one of your personal battles mean you are defining yourself as a homosexual?
No, it doesn’t. . . . All of us are sinners, and sexual sinners. But, if we have turned to Christ, we are new creations, redeemed from slavery to sin through our union with Christ in his death and raised with him by the Spirit to a new life of holiness, while we wait for a glorious future in his presence when he returns.
These awesome realities define me and direct me to the kind of life I should live. In acknowledging that I know something of all eight battles covered in my book, therefore, I’m not making a revelation about my fundamental identity, other than that, like all Christians, I am a sinner saved by grace, called to live in the brokenness of a fallen world until Christ returns and brings all our battles to an end.
He says a lot more that is very helpful, too.  Read the whole thing.

[HT: JT]

Tuesday, February 19, 2013

Tim's Story - You Are Not Alone

As I listened to Tim's story (below), I was struck again with how important the loving reaction of his friends was to his revelation of homosexual desires.

One of Tim's friends, Eric Teetsel, wrote about their friendship in an article titled, "My Gay Roommate."
One lesson in particular stands out from the rest. Tim vacillated between acceptance of his sexual inclinations and the greater calling of his faith for years before finally finding rest in the decision to let Jesus be enough. That arduous journey was made much, much more difficult by voices from within the Church encouraging him to embrace his inclination to homosexuality.
The debates in our culture and churches about homosexuality are not just theoretical. They are about real people with real lives.


Note: I don't know why, but sometimes the words don't match the video. Listen to it, even if you don't watch.

[HT: Denny Burk]

Wednesday, February 13, 2013

It's OK to Fight Homosexual Sin

It was 1994. I was 15 years old when the epiphany hit me that times were changing and I was eventually going to have a socially acceptable problem.
This sudden awareness started the clock on a grueling battle for my sexuality. I was conscious of the fact that I was different from the other girls at the age of five, and I had lived silently through ten years of gender confusion and attraction to women by age fifteen. I wanted desperately to be “over it” by the time it was going to be acceptable, even normal, to be gay.
And that meant a fight.
Homosexuality is not a tender enemy.
But, I’m thankful for the affliction because it made a warrior and a lover of me.
For my entire twenty-three year search, I was never alone. When I made the decision to reach for help, people loved me. They prayed, listened, cried, and held me. They believed the best was coming and waited tirelessly for the seeds of life to bear fruit in my soul. By patient love they demonstrated my Father’s heart. The best of them never violated my will, created forceful situations, made rules for me to follow, rushed me to conclusions, or prescribed remedies. They gave me no reason to mistrust God by their own leadership styles. They didn’t make my sin any bigger than theirs. They didn’t freak out when I fell. They just spoke truth, and waited with me until I could see God. Because that’s the promise for the pure in heart. They see God.
Notice how many stories of true change involve someone loving like Christ does.

Christy has experienced victory in this fight.
Sometimes I agreed with God about my sexuality because He is Lord, and love is a choice, and that is all. My emotions were left out of the equation so many times because I had to believe either my feelings were lying to me or God was. I purposed in my heart to honor God’s design no matter how it felt, for a very, very long time. I could feel in the waiting that Life was at work in me. Hope was at work in me.
There was never a pinnacle moment when I knew, “I’m not gay anymore. I feel different.” My liberation was unceremonious. Freedom matured in me through a process, from the seeds of truth that God planted and people watered along the way. It wasn’t one decision I made not to be gay, there were many. Like Proverbs 4:18 says, “… the path of the righteous is like the light of dawn, that shines brighter and brighter until the full day.”

Friday, February 08, 2013

Sex Matters - EFCA Theology Conference Audio

The audio is now available for the EFCA Theology Conference I mentioned a few weeks ago.

I am going to download it right now and start listening.

Copied from the official page:

Ben Mitchell
(Ben was unable to attend the conference because of a medical issue. His presentation was recorded via phone. His first session is being re-recorded and will be added at a later date.)
Dan Beals
(Dan Beal was also not able to join the conference due to a medical emergency. His session is being re-recorded with improved audio.)
Panels

Wednesday, January 30, 2013

Stories of Same-Sex Attraction and Change


One of the strongest ministries out there right now for gospel-centered change for sexual brokenness is Harvest USA.

I am currently reading their excellent little book Sexual Sanity for Men: Re-Creating Your Mind in a Crazy Culture. I got the meet the author, David White, at the CCEF Conference this last Fall.


This second book is written by Ellen Dykas, the women's ministry coordinator for Harvest USA.

Last month, she gave us a set of four encouraging stories of women whose hearts, lives, and identities have been changed by the gospel.




Wednesday, January 23, 2013

Robert Gagnon on Homosexuality and the Modern Church

One of the key speakers next week, at the EFCA Theology conference, will be Robert Gagnon, a leading Christian scholar on the topic of homosexuality.

Last Fall, DesiringGod posted an interview with Gagnon answering some significant questions on the topic:

“The Church in a Homosexual Culture: An Interview with Robert Gagnon” (32 minutes): 
  • What are the biblical and the structural prerequisites for a sexual union that magnifies God and honors his created design?
  • From that, what constitutes sinful sexual practices?
  • Does the Bible say anything about gender reassignment surgery?
  • Is homosexuality a modern phenomenon? Just how pervasive was homosexuality in the Greco-Roman world of the Apostle Paul?
  • By voting yes to the Minnesota Marriage Amendment, are Christians oppressing the freedoms of the gay and lesbian community? Why or why not?
  • What advice do you have for churches seeking to preach against the sin of homosexuality, and make sure the church doors are wide open and welcoming to all those in the homosexual community?
“Same-Sex Temptations in the Church: An Interview with Robert Gagnon” (30 minutes):
  • What role does the Church play in demythologizing sexuality in modern culture?
  • In the life of a professing Christian, what makes homosexual practice “an act of unbelief”?
  • Should we be okay with a professing believer who self-identifies as “a celibate gay Christian”?
  • What advice do you have for Christian parents who are fearful that their children will experience same-sex attraction in the teen years?
  • What are churches doing well in engaging those who struggle with same-sex attraction? What are churches doing poorly?
  • What guiding principles will help us to love and reach out to our homosexual neighbors?